How We Pick Our Riot Fest Ticket Giveaway Winners (8 Giveaway Tools Compared)

November 19, 2026

Every year we give away Riot Fest tickets, and every year the same two things happen. The post gets more comments than we can scroll, and someone asks how the winner was picked.

Both are fair. A giveaway is only fun if people believe it was drawn straight. So here is exactly how we do it, and the tools we use for it.

Disclosure: the tools below were built by our owner's software studio, partly because of giveaways like this one. We use them ourselves. Each has a free tier, so you can check anything we say here.

What a fair comment giveaway needs

  1. Every comment gets read. Instagram shows a comment count, but an app has to actually load each one. A tool that quietly stops at a few hundred is drawing from part of your entries.
  2. Your rules get applied the same way to everyone. One entry per person or one per comment, a tagged friend required or not, your own replies left out.
  3. The result can be shown. A page you can link in your story beats a screenshot.
  4. No password hand-over. You should not have to log in to Instagram through someone else's site to pick a winner from a public post.

The quick comparison

Tool Best for Networks Free up to Paid
Pickfetti Most giveaways, including ours Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, YouTube 1,000 comments a post (300 on TikTok and Facebook); any size if you paste the list One-time pass from $4.99
PickFaire Giveaways where people will question the draw Instagram 300 comments One-time pass from $6.99
GiveawaySuite Agencies and social media managers running giveaways for clients Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook 300 comments $29 a month
SorteoComentarios Hosts who work in Spanish Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook 1,000 comments (300 on TikTok and Facebook) One-time pass from $4.99
سحب (sa7b) Hosts who work in Arabic Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook 1,000 comments (300 on TikTok and Facebook) One-time pass from $4.99
WinnerReveal Announcing a winner with a video, or drawing one from a list of names Any (you type or paste the names) Pasted name lists of any size; two video styles $4.99 a video in the other styles
IGComments Getting Instagram comments into a file Instagram 200 comments One-time pass from $4.99
CommentsToSheets Comments from any network in Excel or Google Sheets Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook 1,000 on Instagram, 5,000 on YouTube, 300 on TikTok and Facebook One-time pass from $4.99, or a plan

Which one we use, and when

For the Riot Fest draw itself: Pickfetti. We paste the post link, set the rules (one entry per person, a tagged friend required), and it reads the comments without asking for our Instagram login. It picks the winner and a couple of backups in case the first one never answers, and gives us a results page we can link. It also records a short reveal video, which is what we post in stories.

When a draw has to be beyond argument: PickFaire. It locks the entry list first and then takes its randomness from a public source that nobody controls, so anyone can re-run the draw and get the same winner. It is more ceremony than a ticket giveaway needs, but for a big prize it ends the "rigged" comments before they start.

For the announcement: WinnerReveal. If you already know who won (a raffle at the counter, a drawing at an event), you type the name, pick a style and download a video. No comments involved.

For counting and checking: IGComments and CommentsToSheets. After a giveaway we like to know how many different people entered and who tagged the most friends. IGComments turns an Instagram post's comments into a spreadsheet. CommentsToSheets does the same for TikTok, YouTube and Facebook and can feed a Google Sheet directly.

If you run giveaways for other people: GiveawaySuite. It keeps each client's draws separate and puts the client's name on the results page instead of the tool's.

If your audience is not English-speaking: SorteoComentarios is the same idea in Spanish from the first screen to the receipt, and سحب (sa7b) is in Arabic.

What we have learned running ours

  • Say the rules in the post. "One entry per person, tag a friend, winner drawn Friday" saves a hundred replies.
  • Draw backups. Winners miss messages. A second and third name, drawn at the same time, means you never have to draw twice.
  • Post the proof. Link the results page or post the reveal video. People who did not win are the ones watching.
  • Never ask the winner for money or a password. Scam accounts copy giveaway posts within hours. We say in every post that we only announce from our own account and never ask for payment.

See you at the next one.